Saturday, 6 September 2014

Findings from the Project

After this project, our group has learnt more about the Hock Lee Bus Riots that happened in 1955. We have also come to a conclusion as to why the 1950s and early 1960s should be remembered today, with reference to the Hock Lee Bus Riots.

As a quick introduction, the Hock Lee Bus Riots was one of the worst riots that happened in Singapore, leaving 4 dead and 31 injured. The blog post our group has presented shows us 4 talk points from 2 different perspectives each. We learn more about the difference between the understanding of the problem with the bus drivers themselves and their employers. 

We feel that the 1950s and 1960s are worth remembering because incidents that happened during that period of time have valuable life lessons that we, the future generation, should learn from and improve on so as to create a better future for our descendants. 

For example, the Hock Lee Bus Riots as well as the other riots that happened then teaches us that violence or riots will not solve any problem and that treating people with dignity and respect is a key factor in avoiding similar conflicts. 

It is absolutely logical for the bus drivers to pursue a better life and better working conditions, but because most of the bus drivers were illiterate at that time, they were often treated lightly and underestimated. They felt that the only way they could voice out their wants and be heard was to hold a strike. The strike they held started off as a peaceful strike without any violence but the government decided to send police troops to break off the groups, which was perfectly fine in the eyes of the law, but which at the same time, angered the protesters. Similarly, the Hock Lee Bus Company employers also decided to fire the workers indiscriminately and refused to listen or try to fulfill their employees’ requests. There is nothing illegal about the way the whole incident was handled, but the consequences of the actions that were taken out prove to us that what is legal may not always be the right thing to do. 


Hence, the 1950s and 1960s are worth remembering in order to avoid letting history repeat itself and to mould a better future for everyone, through the lessons we learnt from the Hock Lee Bus Riots.




word count: 393

Comparison of Sources

Both sources A and B, are similar in telling me that the government of Singapore during 1955 was quite chaotic. This can be seen from source A, where "I think you know, when I was first elected and appointed Chief Minister, I was told I had no office, no clerk, no thambi. And oh they couldn't give me any office - it took a long time - government offices were extremely overloaded - and there was a lot of difficulty." This shows that even political leaders' assistants were on strike and that the nation was very unruly at that time. Similarly, source B states that "From early April until the end of December 1955, Singapore witnessed a staggering 260 labour stoppages, walk-offs, go-slows and sit-downs - if we exclude Sundays, that means more than one labour protest every working day." This shows that there was no control over the strikes that were going on daily for 9 months in total. Thus, it can be seen that the government of Singapore during 1955 was quite chaotic. 

Both sources A and B, are different in content in that of when the chaotic period of government started. In source A, it states that '' Last year, this time, in the month of March: a time of agony '' ' This shows that the chaotic period in source A started in March. On the other hand, source B states that '' From early April until the end of December 1955, Singapore witnessed a staggering 260 labor stoppages, walk-offs, go slows and sit-downs. ''
This shows that the chaotic period in source B started in early April and chaotic period of government were different in both sources.